So it's been just over two weeks since I bought a Playstation 3, the first week of which I played it nearly constantly as I resolutely squandered the second half of my vacation playing video games. Now I think I've had plenty of time to form an opinion of the machine and can say that I'm glad I bought it (good thing too, since the thing is ridiculously expensive in Europe!)
First I need to explain why I bought a Playstation 3. I already have a Wii, of course. But the Wii has not been getting a lot of the latest games that I want to play, which only come out on the HD consoles, the PS3 and XBox 360. The Wii has had some stellar titles—Twilight Princess and Metroid Prime Corruption were gaming nirvana, and I don't expect anything on the PS3 to exceed them.
The problem is, there just aren't enough games like that out for the Wii. Even being a new dad with a full time job, I eventually got to the end of Metroid, and found myself with no new titles in my stack. Worse, no upcoming titles to get excited about (except Tiger Woods '09, which I'm hoping will finally give a full golf game on the Wii with good controls—I love Wii Sports Golf and still play it, but there are only nine holes.) The combination of not having any big titles coming on the Wii, and there being a whole load of AAA titles on the HD consoles that I would like to play, made me decide to start saving for a second console.
Secondly, I have a 42" Plasma HDTV at home with beautiful 5.1 surround sound. The problem? There is practically no HDTV to watch in France! I had an upscaling DVD player, but I really wanted to get a Blu-Ray player to be able to watch my TV with the highest quality picture it can display. I was somewhat worried that the difference would be negligeable between a Blu-Ray and an upscaled DVD, but I had seen details on The Fifth Element on Blu-Ray that my mom owns that I had not seen on my superbit DVD version, so I felt it would be worthwhile.
Because the XBox 360 doesn't have Blu-Ray, and because it's goofy appearance looks out of place in a home theatre (not to mention its loud fan noise), the Playstation 3 was the clear choice. Online play is also free on the PS3 whereas one must subscribe on XBox. So how did it turn out?
Well I came very close to backing out. The PS3 in Europe costs an insane 400€, compared to a price of only 260€ in the US. This meant that when I discovered that I could get a good Samsung Blu-Ray player with HDMI 1.3 for only 250€, I had serious second thoughts. Why not just get that player instead, especially since it would work with my Logitech Harmony remote? Eventually though I decided to go through with it, and though the price is too high in Europe, the hardware has not let me down.
Blu Ray is awesome. I have Planet Earth on Blu-Ray, and the picture is just amazing. Emilie walked by when I first put it in and stopped in her tracks. The difference is clearly visible and a serious improvement over DVD—when the sounce material is good. This is real HDTV; a lot of the downloadable and cable content people get in HD has been compressed to save bandwidth and this lessens the quality of the picture, Blu-Ray is the best way to ensure you're getting top quality, and it shows. That said, I hope it will catch on because in audio, consumers have shown they prefer convenience (MP3s) to quality (SACDs and DVD-As, which you may never have even heard of they flopped so bad). There's a lot more marketing behind Blu-Ray though and the picture is so much better (if you have a big-screen HDTV, which not everyone does), so I think its prospects are good.
Uncharted and GTA4 are awesome. These are the two games I've been playing the most; the other two I bought, MGS4 and COD4, also look great but I am saving them for later.
Non region-coded games are awesome. In particular for me because I was able to buy them in the US for way cheaper, but also because as an American in Europe I might want to get games like NCAA Football that I might not otherwise be able to.
Of course, I don't want to give the impression that the thing is perfect, there are some big annoyances as well. I already mentioned the ridiculous European price, but that's not all:
No PS2 compatability is retarded. I would really have liked to be able to play PS2 games because I never bought a PS2, since I thought that would have been an act of infidelity to my dear departed Dreamcast. The Wii plays GameCube games and I have used that to pick up some old GC games on the cheap; there are a lot of PS2 games I would've gotten if they would've worked. It's especially frustrating since the PS3 originally could play PS2 games, but they removed the functionality.
Region coding sucks. PS3 games do not have region codes, but it won't play region 1 DVDs or Blu-Rays. Since I have dozens of zone 1 DVDs, this means that I have to keep my upscaling DVD player hooked up, and can't use the PS3 for everything. Region coding is retarded: imagine if all my books had stopped working because I moved to a different country!
No IR remote capability. To control Blu-Rays with my Logitech Harmony remote I need to buy a third-party dongle, which is annoying.
No SACD or DVD-A playback. Not surprising, but I would've appreciated it, now that HDMI means that these high-fidelity formats don't require a stupid amount of cables to use. Also it appears that, like PS2 compatability, the first PS3s had SACD but it was taken out. D'oh!
There are other little things I could mention, like the ability to install Linux (good), or the web browser (bad, or not as good as the Wii's anyway), but I think that this shows the general idea: I am extremely happy with the PS3 for games and movies, although some of the minor things are slight annoyances, all in all it's a great source of entertainment.