I have explained before my reasons for playing the baroque tenor recorder, and I still enjoy playing that instrument. However, over the last few months, I have been drawn to branch out, and so I thought I would share the process I went through here.
As I mentioned in my recorder article, I originally set out to learn to play the guitar. Progress was halted, however, when I began travelling, and found the guitar too bulky, not to mention fragile and expensive, to want to take with me. The recorder became my portable instrument, with the added benefit of not requiring tuning—and my guitar languished unused at my parents' house.
When my parents sold the house, they asked whether I wanted them to try to ship the guitar to me in France, but I said no, they could just sell it—I was happy with my tenor recorder, and anyway I didn't expect the guitar to be easy to ship safely.
Naturally, it was only a short while after that that I began really hankering to play guitar again.
The main thing that had changed was that I had originally given up the guitar because I was moving around too much, from city to city and country to country. But now that I have bought a house and have settled down for what is expected to be a much longer time frame, suddenly that aspect of instrument selection is a lot less pertinent.
The second thing that changed was I ended up on sick leave for a couple days with a throat infection. Sitting around, I wanted to play music, but the recorder was not an option with my swollen throat! Also, although the recorder is easy to play and can play some nice melodies, I have largely acquired the repertoire that I want on that instrument: it is well suited to haunting melodies like "Greensleeves" and "Simple Gifts", but I was beginning to get bored with those tunes and wanted to branch out more musically. Also the recorder gathers saliva while playing, forcing you to stop and clean it out after only about 20 minutes, which takes away from the experience of playing. Finally, the lack of ability to play chords was beginning to get to me. I wanted something I could do a little more with musically—with a chord progression and a good knowledge of scales and modes you can just kind of "jam" on some instruments, but the recorder is not one of them.
Still, I have a lot of hobbies and not a lot of space, so I am very keen not to let the house fill up with junk as a result. Amassing a collection of musical instruments is precisely the kind of thing I do not want to let myself do. So pianos and vibraphones were out, and the idea of something even smaller than a guitar was an attractive one. So I considered picking up a ukulele instead (remember, I have no pretensions of playing in front of people—I'm just a hobbyist musician so I only have to care about how fun an instrument is to play, not what I look like playing it), but very quickly in the course my research the field expanded to four candidates: ukulele, classical guitar, folk acoustic guitar, or mandolin.
The ukulele quickly fell off the list, though: it's primary advantage to me had been low cost (again, since I'm not that serious about my music I'm not going to spend $900 on an instrument), but looking around I was able to find that there were viable guitar options which were not that much more expensive than a ukulele (the Yamaha C40 classical guitar, for instance), and would offer a lot more options musically. The uke is also easier to learn than the guitar or mandolin, but I don't expect them to be particularly hard, either, so that was not a major factor.
The question then became whether I, who previously played a steel-stringed, folk acoustic guitar, would enjoy a nylon-stringed, classical guitar. Ultimately I decided in the negative—after spending quite a lot of time checking out the Yamaha C40 on YouTube, the only piece that I really saw myself playing on a regular basis was the Super Mario Bros. theme (don't laugh, it really is beautiful on a classical guitar!), and I didn't think the loss of easy chord-strumming would be worth it. The one song I really learned to play well from memory on the guitar back in the day was the Ventures' Walk Don't Run, and it requires fast strumming. I think classical guitar is great—there is a great repertoire out there, I just wasn't able to find what I wanted—and that Yamaha is a steal, but it just isn't really the kind of music I feel like playing these days. (And I'm not interested in growing out my right-hand fingernails, either.)
So, in the steel-stringed, folk acoustic category, my attention went to the Yamaha F310, which is not that much more expensive. I would have thought that this is where the search would have ended (and I can't promise I won't end up getting one eventually), but a few factors drew me to continue looking and to consider the mandolin.
My experience in checking out the mandolin was the opposite of classical guitar: it appeared easier to play than I thought, and the music sounded better. Bluegrass mandolin probably requires more skill than I am likely to acquire (at least for a few years), but the instrument is also used in plenty of other contexts. Before implanting itself as a folk instrument, the mandolin was originally popularised in America as an easy violin: the fingerings are the same as the violin, and so a lot of classical music can be played on it, without having to deal with a bow (and with the benefit of frets). In that respect, there is a lot of music that is similar to what one finds for the recorder. Which is nice for beginners, if a bit dull.
The mandolin occasionally appears in pop and rock songs as well, and I was happy to see what good lessons you can find on YouTube. Losing my Religion by R.E.M., for example, should be easy to learn in a short time, and sounds pretty nice to me. Zeppelin's the Battle of Evermore will be another must.
Very intriguing too was the fact that the mandolin has been taken up in Celtic music. There are a lot of jigs and reels out there for mandolin, with tabs easy to find on the internet, that I think sound very nice. I would really like to be able to play one of these—and for a fun start, I could begin with Spinal Tap's mandolin riff from "Stonehenge" :-)
Still, the guitar had some advantages that I did not want to gloss over, the biggest of which was its universality. A lot of people have guitars—if I could participate in playing a few tunes at parties or when visiting people, that would be cool. It's also more versatile, with a larger range, less typified voice, and far broader repertoire than the mandolin.
What finally decided me, though, was the discovery of how good the mandolin sounds standing in for the balalaika (itself not a very versatile instrument and so not one of my contenders, even though I like Russian folk music). Adding Korobeiniki and Kalinka to my potential repertoire meant that there were now a lot of things I could see myself actually learning on the instrument—more really than I had in mind for the acoustic guitar—and all this on an instrument that would be smaller, cheaper, and easier to learn—but still able to play chords and improvise on without external accompaniment, and all this while being somewhat unique to boot.
So I purchased a Fender FM-100, and am very happy with it. As much as it is embarrassing to return to tunes like Au Clair de la Lune while I master the basics, I'm already getting comfortable playing it. It's quiet enough to play at home without bothering others, it's portable and easy to store (being the same size as a Guitar Hero controller) and much more versatile than the recorder (having a much larger range and being able to play simple chords and doublestops—not that I'm good enough to incorporate these into my playing yet). That said, I had underestimated how only having four strings limits the mandolin in comparison to the guitar: chords are not as full, doublestop options are not as plentiful. Still, though, it is more than enough for a musician of my humble calibre, and with a repertoire spanning Celtic, Slavic, and American folk music, with a few well-known pop tunes thrown in, I am looking forward to having a long and fruitful time with this instrument.